‘THERE IS NO LAW ON PHUKET!’
A long awaited report by the BBC’s South East Asia
correspondent Jonathan Head went to air yesterday on BBC2 in the UK.
correspondent Jonathan Head went to air yesterday on BBC2 in the UK.
It is difficult to guess what affect it will have if any;
but it was good to see the BBC dealing with frauds against foreigners in
Thailand, which in this case impacted on
Irishman Colin Vard and Briton Ian Rance, who were cleaned out of everything in
Phuket in a conspiracy between lawyers, police, money lenders and government
officials.
but it was good to see the BBC dealing with frauds against foreigners in
Thailand, which in this case impacted on
Irishman Colin Vard and Briton Ian Rance, who were cleaned out of everything in
Phuket in a conspiracy between lawyers, police, money lenders and government
officials.
 |
| Ian Rance with family before his world fell apart |
The piece was titled ‘Defrauded by My Wife and Criminals in Thailand’.
But cheating Thai wives were merely the gullible catalysts in these cases – and
these cases happen where there are no Thai wives at all of course.
But cheating Thai wives were merely the gullible catalysts in these cases – and
these cases happen where there are no Thai wives at all of course.
The property of both men in Thailand was of course
distributed among the thieves and in both cases, as usual; officials not only
took no action, but also played a major part.
distributed among the thieves and in both cases, as usual; officials not only
took no action, but also played a major part.
The great thing about television is that we can get to see
the faces of those taking part in the fraud and those who actually can do
something expressing sympathy and understanding while doing very little and
probably have no intention of doing so.
the faces of those taking part in the fraud and those who actually can do
something expressing sympathy and understanding while doing very little and
probably have no intention of doing so.
The plights of these two families who have been impoverished
by the system are of course just the tip of the iceberg of one of the world’s
great fraud hubs.
by the system are of course just the tip of the iceberg of one of the world’s
great fraud hubs.
And of course foreign
criminals did not take too long to work out that this could be a good little
earner for them too.
criminals did not take too long to work out that this could be a good little
earner for them too.
 |
| No camera! says Rance’s lawyer as Head shows him the signature he forged |
I enjoyed seeing a lawyer squirm and then pretend it was
quite in order for him to forge his clients’ signature in his absence, and the
Deputy Governor of Phuket feigning surprise at the five years Ian Rance has
been battling for justice, while knowing it could take a life-time, literally.
quite in order for him to forge his clients’ signature in his absence, and the
Deputy Governor of Phuket feigning surprise at the five years Ian Rance has
been battling for justice, while knowing it could take a life-time, literally.
 |
| Head interrogating Rance’s lawyer. The Flying Sporran would of course have turned the lamp on the lawyer |
I also enjoyed the Royal Thai Police spokesman (top) announcing
that he was not there to argue he was there to solve Colin Vard’s problems. Actually the RTP promised to solve the problem
in two months – that deadline went by a long time ago.
that he was not there to argue he was there to solve Colin Vard’s problems. Actually the RTP promised to solve the problem
in two months – that deadline went by a long time ago.
It’s a pity the BBC2 piece did not contain this latest non
development – but I did not see the lead into the programme or the final
comment by studio presenter Victoria Derbyshire.
development – but I did not see the lead into the programme or the final
comment by studio presenter Victoria Derbyshire.
 |
| Vard accepts promises at the Royal Thai Police headquarters in Bangkok. |
The long delay in transmission may have been as a result of
the BBC not coming up with a slot easily.
Frauds against foreigners in Thailand are at the bottom of news agendas.
It is the same with boiler room stories. It’s the ‘fool parted with his money’
syndrome I’m afraid. ‘Don’t they know
Thailand is corrupt’? ‘Serves them right
for taking a young Thai wife’ etc.
the BBC not coming up with a slot easily.
Frauds against foreigners in Thailand are at the bottom of news agendas.
It is the same with boiler room stories. It’s the ‘fool parted with his money’
syndrome I’m afraid. ‘Don’t they know
Thailand is corrupt’? ‘Serves them right
for taking a young Thai wife’ etc.
But both these men have been defrauded of millions and theyare part and parcel of systematic frauds common place in places in Thailand foreigners
put down new roots – and when they tried to expose it they put their lives on
the line. That is not in many guide books or government ‘travel advisory’ that
I have seen.
And they also face being sued.
“This is the result of laws that punish people for outing criminals and scammers – you get sued back as the victim and the perpetrator gets off.
It also stops you warning the public about corrupt lawyers, money laundering banks and court judgements that are absurd. This is how a cheating corrupt society which is what we have in Thailand perpetuates itself”.
The above is what Ian Rance posted on this site’s Facebook page. Readers of this site will recognise the scenario.
And in these cases while the wives took the initial steps
(by trying to sell their husbands properties) they in fact got little of the
rewards, while the wolves waiting in the wings, all from so called respectable
professions had a feast.
The establishment is the criminal I am afraid.
Good effort by Head (above) and his team. Pity it will be missed by
many. It’s part of Thailand’s black economy.
many. It’s part of Thailand’s black economy.
Link updated: But if not working -Google search title will work
The link to "Defrauded by my wife…" could not be opened.
I am not in Thailand, for the record.
That link is invalid.
Glad to see the news about Thailand is bursting out at the seams. Of course the sex-tourists and wifey seekers won't stay away, but at least others who were for years getting censored information such as what Thai Visa Forum was/is offering can now make slightly more informed opinions on whether or not to set up a life here.
How about giving your tedious misandry a rest, Ms S. What has this got to do with "sex tourists and wifey seekers" and what useful information on the subject of this report was ever provided by the vast majority of the morons that populate Thaivisa?
Cant find it on the Beeeeb Drummond and the link is broken.
Problem with the program….if I ever see it is…… Head is just tweaking the tigers tail….as they say "don't tease the tiger".
When is the main stream UK/ world media going publicise Thailand's epidemic of corruption and organised crime?
It doesn't matter how much money was taken off these guys (although it does make good headlines), it is the fact that they had everything they had taken from them. That and the family heartache that this leads to.
As D hasmtt given the deatails of the program….
Its Victoria Derbyshire, Friday 18th at 09.15.
Not exactally the program time it should be….I was thinking the main prime time would be fitting.
This one works:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p032t97v
The justice for Jessie campaign seems to have run out if steam… The police were probably just stringing them along hoping people would simply forget eventually…
Here are the usual Five Steps in a Thai "Crackdown" Tim:
1. Wild enthusiasm, tons of talking, table thumping and a call for "heads to roll."
2. Slow disenchantment begins, when it is realized politicians or "people of influence" are involved and will never be investigated.
3. Total despair starts all over again when the case goes nowhere – as rarely are Thai people of importance ever seriously arrested or even investigated.
4. The hunt for suitable scapegoats starts – preferably a poor, uneducated person – even better if a foreigner (Farang, Burmese or a Cambodian) can be blamed.
5. Promotion of the guilty and prosecution of the innocent.
Gotta love the thai copper with the proper english accent..
Link now working – many thanks to whoever for making that happen.
This should be made compulsory viewing for every Westerner who arrives in Phuket.
Show it on every flight – every cruise ship – which visits the island.
Have it on a continuous loop in every bar – every hotel room – whatever, just to get the message across.